99 on Metacritic and 98 on OpenCritic: an extraordinary critical debut

GTA 6 has put a number on thirteen years of expectations: 99 out of 100 on Metacritic for PS5. In our direct November 18 check at 11:25 UTC, OpenCritic shows a 98 average and 100% recommendation, with 59 reviews listed. Commercial release remains scheduled for November 19, but the first wave of criticism already presents an exceptional reception.

The context makes 99 stand out. Metacritic lists the original 1998 Ocarina of Time at 99, GTA IV at 98 and versions of GTA V and Red Dead Redemption 2 at 97. In this first snapshot, GTA VI reaches a number associated with historical reference points. That is a striking result without turning it into a definitive ranking of the greatest game ever made.

These figures describe the check, rather than a permanently settled score. Additional reviews can move averages. The 99 cited here belongs to PS5 on Metacritic; OpenCritic’s 98 is the figure on its aggregated game page. A platform-specific score should not automatically be assigned to every version.

OpenCritic’s two figures also need separating. A 100% recommendation does not mean every reviewer awarded a perfect score. It describes recommendation under the aggregator’s criteria. Metacritic uses a weighted average. Review sets and aggregation methods can differ, so a one-point gap is not a contradiction.

What four reviews highlight: a responsive world and a relationship at its center

The interesting part begins beyond the number. We selected four original reviews to understand the reasoning behind their scores. They discuss exploration, characters and systems without requiring story spoilers, and their enthusiasm comes with differences in emphasis.

Official promotional screenshot of Vice City’s waterfront and urban surroundings.
Vice City in an official GTA VI promotional screenshot. © Rockstar Games. Open full-size screenshot ↗ · Official gallery

VGC — 5/5: the relationship matters alongside the spectacle

VGC places Jason and Lucia’s relationship at the center of its assessment and highlights interactivity across the world and missions. Its account gives the people and events within Leonida weight beyond the map’s size. It also notes occasional small drops from the 30 FPS target in dense situations, without changing its five-star overall assessment.

VGC · Análisis de Grand Theft Auto 6 ↗

GamesRadar+ — 5/5: details connect to what you do

GamesRadar+ highlights interconnected systems, environmental reactions and protagonists who give the experience cohesion. Its PS5 Pro review declares more than a hundred hours of play and treats detail as something that contributes to the experience. Police pressure supplies a reservation: even minor offences can become frustrating. That demand does not prevent its five-star verdict.

GamesRadar+ · GTA 6 review ↗

Noisy Pixel — 9/10: enthusiasm with pacing reservations

Noisy Pixel praises the world and leads while questioning long stretches of limited narrative progress. Its PS5 review also identifies inconsistent police responses and overly forgiving checkpoints. The nine and Must-Play recommendation coexist with those reservations, making it useful for readers who want to understand possible friction alongside the praise.

Noisy Pixel · Grand Theft Auto VI review ↗

Loot Level Chill — 10/10: variety and improved driving and shooting

Loot Level Chill emphasizes immersion, varied activities, driving and shooting improvements. After more than seventy declared hours on PS5, it describes a world that invites continued play. Its ten still allows for minor technical awkwardness; the review considers the strengths much more significant.

Loot Level Chill · Grand Theft Auto VI review ↗

Why a near-perfect score can still include criticism

Reservations help translate a score into your preferences. One player enjoys a very extensive experience; another feels it loses momentum. Someone welcomes pursuits that demand more attention, while another finds them intrusive. A high average cannot remove those differences.

The selected reviews evaluate the overall experience. Their praise carries substantial weight even where they find areas to improve. That does not make the concerns irrelevant. If pacing, driving or police responses matter particularly to you, reading those passages is more useful than choosing between 98 and 99.

Performance deserves the same precision. An overall score is not a stability measurement across every console and scene. A reviewer’s PS5 Pro experience cannot replace testing a standard PS5 or Xbox Series S. Hardware decisions benefit from coverage of the version you will actually use.

Critic and player ratings also represent different things. This article concerns professional reviews published around launch, rather than a collective public verdict. An average can inform a purchase without predicting exactly how your first hours in Leonida will feel.

From GOTY controversy to published criticism

Yesterday’s debate concerned GTA VI’s eight Game Awards nominations before its release. Today there are published reviews and arguments to read. The discussion gains evidence beyond expectations, promotional images and Rockstar’s history, even as much of the public awaits unlocking.

This start strengthens GTA VI’s case without Metacritic or OpenCritic deciding GOTY. A score does not automatically become votes or remove the other contenders. The ceremony follows its own process. The 99 and 98 describe the initial critical response rather than an award already granted.

What makes this wave noteworthy is the reasoning accompanying the enthusiasm: meaningful leads, a responsive setting and activities that encourage exploration. Reservations arrive too. Together they offer more information than a slogan about perfection.

If you are counting down to playing, our setup and download guides can help. If you remain unsure, start with the linked reviews and the aspects you care about. The numbers attract attention; the arguments explain why.

Sources & editorial notes

Published November 18, 2026. Scores checked directly in Metacritic’s and OpenCritic’s public HTML at 11:25 UTC / 12:25 mainland Spain: PS5 Metascore 99; OpenCritic Top Critic Average 98 and Critics Recommend 100%, with 59 reviews listed. We read the original VGC, GamesRadar+, Noisy Pixel and Loot Level Chill reviews. Summaries are paraphrases, not our own play impressions. GamesRadar+ identifies PS5 Pro; Noisy Pixel and Loot Level Chill identify PS5. We do not generalize those tests to every console. This is a dated snapshot and figures can change. Cover generated with AI; the interior image is official Rockstar promotional material. Vice Route has not played or scored GTA VI.

Metacritic · Grand Theft Auto VI ↗OpenCritic · Grand Theft Auto VI ↗Metacritic · Cómo se calcula el Metascore ↗VGC · Análisis de Grand Theft Auto 6 ↗GamesRadar+ · GTA 6 review ↗Noisy Pixel · Grand Theft Auto VI review ↗Loot Level Chill · Grand Theft Auto VI review ↗Rockstar Games · GTA VI Launch Gallery ↗Read our editorial standards
Back to the library